From

Location

Message

Date Posted

Webster, NY

On average, how long does it take before the seedling breaks through the soil, after germination?

Thanks for any information you can give me.

5/4/2004 7:20:13 AM

Knopp, Germany

I only sand the sides and then place them in their containers, no soaking. I have found that using a 1 pint ice cream container, they break through in 4-5 days and in a bigger, 1 gallon ice cream container, they take 6-7 days. Not sure why, but it has done that for me now 2 years in a row.

5/4/2004 7:25:37 AM

[email protected]

After the 8 hour warm soak & moist towel baggie pre-germination treatment, my 842 Eaton was breaking soil in 48 hours. The 805 Pukos took 72 hours but has been growing faster ever since. In 4 days from emergence, both had sent roots to the bottom of the 12" deep pots.

These times seem consistent with all our other germinating tests & experiences.

Temperature seems to play the single most important role. We kept everything here at 83F this year which is down 5 degrees from 2003 when we experienced 2 failed seeds to rot in 2003. More drama at higher temps, but larger losses too. At least here anyway.

5/4/2004 8:24:40 AM

Webster, NY

The seeds germinated in 3 days. This is the fifth day and I am hoping to see something poking through the soil soon. But I can't keep the pots at 80 degrees. Thanks guys...

5/4/2004 10:10:15 AM

[email protected]

Another consideration: If the radicle is on the long side coming out of a baggie, we have to be *VERY* careful putting it into soil. Pressing down by hand can prove fatal. To lessen the chance for disaster, I prefer to drop small amount of dryish soil into the seedlings hole & settle it with rain water a little at a time. Breaking off the radicle is fatal &/or season limiting every time.

5/4/2004 11:05:27 AM

Mine were filed and soaked in water overnight, then put in the dirt in 5 quart ice cream buckets. All were up within 4 1/2 days of the soaking.

5/4/2004 3:53:59 PM

Independence, MO

I am fresh here, but here is what I did...
I did everything the old fashioned way.
Store bough topsoil, dropped my seeds in (point down), covered with saran wrap and put rubber band around them.
Heating pad below pots (that I sat in aluminum pie pans) with a small lamp above each one (40 watt bulb)
I also filed the seeds...

620 Boyton came up in just 3 days, and stubborn 692 Swarts came up in 5 (The seed was large and fat and i heard they sometimes take longer)

I was concerned the 4th day so I took a peek with a toothpick, and sure enough I had roots going and one side of the seed opening. The 5th day was a charm.

Don't give up hope!

5/4/2004 4:46:37 PM

Webster, NY

Well, 7 days after soaking and filing, and 5 days after germination, the 419 pukos is up and running. I also see a crack in the soil where the 895 Nesbitt is coming through. Here we go!

5/5/2004 7:27:17 AM

Syracuse, NY

i'm not sure if it has any bearing on the case here, but i would expect that the longer time it takes for the seedling to break the surface in a larger pot as opposed to a smaller one has SOMETHING to do with the roots getting to the bottom of their present container-----if it has to go
twice as far to throw-down its first, main root, as one that is in a container that requires half that distance to achieve that same goal, i would expect that the larger-containered one is gonna take a little longer.....needs to get its "groove on" before making an appearance....one o' my thoughts, anyway. 'pal2

5/5/2004 6:11:06 PM